As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
If you’re in a hurry and just want to find out what the best car seat protector is, I’d recommend the Brica Seat Guardian Car Seat Protector.
In general, babies and toddlers aren’t known for keeping things neat and tidy. Once you have a little one to cart around in the back of your car, it can be a good idea to look into a good car seat protector.
In this article, I am breaking down the best car seat protectors, and in the end, I’ll choose the winner.
Here are the car seat protectors I will be reviewing:
Biggest Benefits Of Car Seat Protectors
After a couple of years carting kids around, there is a good chance that the upholstery in the back seat of your car will be ruined. Unless, of course, you use a car seat protector.
These protectors keep your seats safe from all of the little spills and other messes that will otherwise wind up on your upholstery.
Perhaps even more important is protection from the indentations that car seats can leave in your car. A lot of parents notice these for the first time when they remove their child’s car seat. It turns out that having a hard car seat sitting on your upholstery leaves a deep indentation. In some cases the indentation comes out after a while, and in other cases it’s permanent. With a good car seat protector though, this isn’t an issue.
In general protectors are fairly inexpensive. So, they can actually save you money over time since they can eliminate the need to get your seats professionally cleaned, restored or re-upholstered.
What To Look For In A Car Seat Protector
There are a few key features that you will want to look for when shopping for a car seat protector:
- Coverage. Some car seat protectors only cover the bottom part of the seat. Others cover the back and the front as well. All things being equal, it’s better to have more coverage.
- Non-slip. Look for car seats that have no-slip traction. This will help ensure that the car seat doesn’t move around or slip.
- Storage. With all of the things that you need to carry around for babies and toddlers, it never hurts to have more storage. That said, I consider this to be more of a nice to have feature than a must have feature, since most cars have plenty of storage already.
- Color and style. When you’re thinking about buying a car seat protector, it’s easy to focus on features and forget about appearance. It’s going to be sitting in your car for several years though. So, you will want to find something that you like and that complements the colors in your car.
My Top Car Seat Protector Reviews
I have spent a TON of time analyzing car protectors, and have narrowed the list down to my top five. The ones included below are all great products, and come with different features. There are also options at different price points, so hopefully there is something for everyone.
Britax has earned a stellar reputation in the world of baby gear. So, it’s no surprise that they have come out with a very nice car seat protector.
This car seat protector has raised edges to catch all of the spills that will happen along the ride. It’s great for catching crumbs that fall too. So, your car will end up being considerably cleaner with this in place.
The protector itself is made of rubber. So, it’s really easy to take out and clean off. The rubber material also helps ensure that your car seat won’t slip.
It’s designed with a front seat guard that hangs over the front of the seat. So, if your little passenger’s feet hang down, they won’t scuff the front part of the seat.
Some parents report that the rubber is a little on the thin side. So, car seats can still leave indentations in some cases.
It’s also worth pointing out that this one only covers the bottom part of the seat. So, if you have your child in a rear facing car seat, there is nothing to protect the seat back from your little one’s shoes.
This seat protector is made of PVC leather which is quite durable and is also easy on the eyes.
It’s thick and sturdy, which means car seats won’t leave an indentation on your seats. This is actually one of the key benefits for any car seat protector, and this one really delivers.
This protector comes with three built in pockets for storage. This can be really useful for keeping things like extra tissues or baby wipes nearby.
One issue that some parents reported is that it can slip a little. I suppose this is a downside of the PVC leather surface. It shouldn’t be too big of an issue as long as you secure your car seat properly. After all, a lot of people use car seats in cars that have leather upholstery.
The Brica Seat Guardian is made by Munchkin, and it’s quite impressive. In fact, I think it’s the best car seat protector out there.
This protector is well designed and fits well with most cars. It also has a rear facing kick mat to protect the back of the seat when you’re using a rear facing car seat.
This one has a front seat guard that hangs over the front part of the seat as well. So, it provides protection when your little passenger’s feet hang over the edge.
The material has dual grip traction to eliminate unwanted movement, and ensure that there is no slipping.
This protector does a really nice job of protecting the seats in your car from the indentations that a car seat can leave behind.
The fabric is also easy to clean. This is really nice since spills do happen from time to time.
If there is a knock on this one, it’s that it doesn’t have any pockets for storage. While pockets might be nice, it’s not a deal breaker since most cars have plenty of storage anyway.
Summer Infant has come out with a nice protector that checks most of the boxes.
It’s made from super grip vinyl. So, you can feel confident that your car seat won’t slip.
The protector itself is quite thick and durable. So, it does a really nice job of protecting your upholstery from the indents that a car seat can leave behind.
This one includes both a back seat protector and front guard. So, your seats will be well covered and well protected.
It comes with pockets for storage, which is a nice bonus.
The one issue with this one is that there is no head rest strap. So, the back part of the protector flops down at times.
This one is made of premium PVC leather and wins serious style points.
The protector itself is not too thick, and not too thin, but somewhere in the middle. This works well in most cars. However, some parents did report that they wished it was thicker so that it would better protect upholstery from car seat indents.
It has small pouches for storage. So, you will have an extra place to store small items.
Some parents reported that the bottom part was barely big enough to fit a car seat. It would be good if it was a little bigger to provide some margin for large car seats.
I feel good recommending any of the car protectors in this post. However, my favorite one is the Brica Seat Guardian Car Seat Protector. Having said that, if a different one has a feature you really like or if you just like the style better, by all means go for that one.